REVIEW: Maher makes religion a mockery in his documentary
Amadeo Lopez
Issue date: 9/29/08 Section: The Scene
|
Bill Maher, who is well-known for his sarcastic humor and tough critiques on politics, has taken on religion. His new movie, Religulous, which debuts on Oct. 3, starts out as a documentary and ends up with Maher's trying to convert everyone to atheism. Maher tells his interview victims that he wants their opinions about the Bible, God and religion, but instead he ends up challenging their personal beliefs.
The film introduces Maher's statement on religion - that extremism is crazy. Then, with no rhyme nor reason, it rambles on in a poorly organized way.
Religulous lacks direction or purpose. It presents random interviews and brief facts without any in-depth analysis, making the documentary hard to follow.
The lack of intellectual commentary challenges the film's credibility. The inclusion of bizarre clips of extremist acts and behaviors are nothing new, they could easily be found on YouTube - which only adds to the lack of creativity.
It seems Maher was trying to be smart, but a few mistakes are found in the film. For, example, in one part of the credits, it states that Amsterdam is in Germany, when its actually located in the Netherlands.
The sarcastic humor makes the audience laugh, but that's it.
I sincerely expected to learn something, but this was like asking George Lopez to do deep research on illegal immigration - the result would be funny but catastrophic and non-intellectual.
amadeo_lopez_texas@yahoo.com
2008 Woodie Awards
Viewing Comments 1 - 4 of 4
Michael
posted 9/29/08 @ 10:22 PM CST
What do you expect from Maher? He takes the same tired line he always does: He pretends he is "open-minded," the decides that because there are some bad Christians and extremist Muslims out there, that all religions is therefore bad. (Continued…)
Ariana L-C
posted 10/14/08 @ 11:48 PM CST
I can't say anything in-depth because I haven't gone to see it yet.
But I'll say this:
Unoriginal though it may be, I was under the impression that he was questioning people not only to find out what they know (or think they know), but he was questioning their beliefs because many of those with faith seem to not have the courage to question it themselves. (Continued…)
Luis Perez
posted 10/22/08 @ 5:56 PM CST
I agree with this review.
salman22
Salman Khan
posted 11/21/08 @ 12:18 AM CST
This is a TEST Comment
Salman Khan
Salman Khan
http://www.google.com/
This is ridiculous. I dont think it is right at all.
Post a Comment